In God and the Weight of Evidence: Essays on the Philosophy of Paul Draper. Routledge. forthcomingBayesian arguments have come to play an important role in the debate over theism. They offer clarity, precision, and the ability to reckon the impact of disparate pieces of evidence. But there is a devil in the details: given the infinity of possible creations, natural axiological constraints on creation grind the mathematical gears of Bayesianism to a halt. In this chapter, I outline the conflict,